What the provider ends up holding
A typical signup produces an email address, a payment method, a billing country, and a creation timestamp. Even with a genuine no-logs policy on traffic, that record exists in billing systems and is subject to ordinary financial record-keeping obligations.
This is why anonymous signup is scored separately from logging in our rubric. They are different exposures and a provider can be excellent at one and indifferent to the other.
The options, ranked by what they actually remove
Each step removes a different link between you and the subscription.
- Account number instead of email: removes the identifier most likely to be reused elsewhere
- Cash by post: removes the financial trail entirely, and a small number of providers accept it
- Monero: designed for untraceability, and accepted by fewer providers
- Bitcoin: pseudonymous, not anonymous — the ledger is public and exchange onboarding is identified
- Prepaid card bought with cash: removes the link to your bank, subject to local rules on registration
- Gift card or voucher: some providers accept them, which is effectively cash at one remove
The mistake almost everyone makes
Using a personal email and a personal card, then treating the subscription as anonymous. The provider now has an identity, a payment method and a billing address, regardless of what the traffic policy says.
The second mistake is buying cryptocurrency on an identified exchange and paying directly from it. The chain from your verified account to the provider is public and permanent.
Avoid
- Assuming Bitcoin is anonymous — it is a public ledger with identified on-ramps
- Reusing an email address that appears in breach databases alongside your real name
- Paying with a card and then worrying about the no-logs policy, which is the smaller exposure
When none of this is necessary
For most readers it is not. If your goal is to stop your ISP building a browsing profile, a card payment and an email are irrelevant to that goal. This page is for people whose threat model includes the provider’s billing records, and it is worth being honest that most people’s does not.